Nose-Zapping Wearable Simulates Smells With Electricity
Jas Brooks, a long-haired engineer who looks like he could be a roadie for a hair metal band Moonlight, sat blindfolded in a room with electrodes in his nose and let people stir the smells over the internet.
"It definitely looks ... awful," they told Digital Trends, comparing the experimental setup to the Milgram Experiment, a controversial series of 1960s experiments conducted by a Yale psychologist that tested willingness to shock participants with electric batons to administer.
However, in Stanley Milgram's experiments, the participants didn't actually kill people. Unbeknownst to them, participants were tested to see if they were willing to obey a person of authority if they did something they thought was unreasonable. In the Brooks experimental setup, Brooks actually received electrical power from the people at the controls. These happened by chance in the form of warm, wasabi-like sensations or sharp vinegar vapors instead of bumps.
"It doesn't hurt," said Brooks. "I just sat there and thought, 'Oh yes, I can feel that. I'm just noticing that.' The basic setting was that I had this blindfold and there was this screen with instructions. It was this interface that I designed with my nose and a right and left button. You could virtually click on it to test the sensor. "
Sniff out the future of technology
Brooks, a Ph.D. Student in the computer science department at the University of Chicago's Human-Computer Integration Lab, focuses on the shape of the technology to come. And based at least on this recent experiment, one shape technicians might take could be a pair of electrodes held in place by tiny magnets and inserted into the wearer's nose.
Human-Computer Integration Laboratory, University of ChicagoTo imagine it, imagine some kind of high-tech anti-snoring device or the kind of cyborg data collection accessory that Jack Dorsey of Twitter could trade in for his nose ring at Burning Man. The tiny, wireless, battery-operated wearable recognizes when the wearer inhales and then uses its electrodes to stimulate the septum, the piece of cartilage in the nose that separates the nostrils.
Digital Trends previously covered the work of the Human-Computer Integration Lab, when researchers (including Brooks) developed a technique to replicate temperature in virtual reality by pumping odorless chemicals with trace elements of capsaicin and menthol to create a sensation of heat and simulate cold. This was done with a power-saving attachment that was attached to a VR display. This time around, however, the device the team developed does not involve any actual chemical stimulation at all. The wearer does not actually smell an external odor; they just tickled one of the clusters of nerves associated with smell that they think it is them.
"Most people may know that we sense smell with our olfactory bulb, but really odor is a multimodal sensation," said Brooks. “We have two systems that to our little perception. We have this olfactory bulb, and then we have the nerve endings in our nose that perceive things like the sharpness of vinegar, which is a very clear sensation conveyed through that nerve, and things like the refreshing aspect of mint.
The Bluetooth nasal wearable hums this latter trigeminal nerve region to do its trick. This easier-to-reach nerve cluster (easier than the olfactory bulb behind the eyeball) adds certain olfactory sensations, which the brain then mixes with the olfactory bulb data to evoke certain olfactory sensations.
A brief history of smells
Brooks and the rest of the team's work is cutting edge. But this isn't the first time the world has looked at the concept of olfactory technology. On April 1, 2013, Google announced its Google Nose project, a new initiative from the tech giant to expand search space into the olfactory field. A video produced by Google showed Product Manager Jon Wooley how smell is a crucial part of how we navigate the world, but how it has been gruesomely overlooked by previous search methods.
The idea behind Google Nose was to build on a Google Aroma database of 15 million “scentibytes” from around the world to enable users to “search for smells”. For example, by clicking a new Google Smell button while using a laptop, desktop or mobile device, a user could hold their phone up to a flower and receive positive identification based on its scent. "By cutting photons with infrasound waves, Google Nose Beta temporarily aligns molecules to emulate a specific odor," explains the video.
Unfortunately, it was more of an April Fool's joke than a real product. While it was fun, this is also an indication of how olfactory technology has been treated many times in recent history. Nobody denies that olfactory senses are strong (there's a reason people talk about the importance of making fresh bread when you are doing house tours to sell your house), but olfactory sense is hard to use, for example, create personalized sound bubbles with earbuds or control what the eye sees through a changing video display.
Efforts to do so have routinely been ridiculed by critics. For example, the long-dead Smell-O-Vision is often laughingly viewed as the low point of cinema play in the mid-20th century, when it lost ground to television. The first Smell-O-Vision film, Scent of Mystery from the 1960s, used plastic tubing to pump an automated fragrance onto the theater seats. The 30 different smells, ranging from Ferume to shoe polish to wine, have been designed to match what is happening on the screen.
An ad for the film read: “They moved first (1895)! Then they talked (1927)! Now they smell (1960)! ”It stank as a gimmick.
The scent of fresh rain?
With this latest work from the Human-Computer Integration Lab, olfactory control is much better possible. For example, one of the unusual features of the device is that it can smell in both stereo and mono. That means it can activate each electrode independently, which is why the Brooks virtual control panel described earlier had separate buttons for left and right. Stereo sniffing is noteworthy as it is not part of how we normally perceive flavors in the real world.
Human-Computer Integration Laboratory, University of ChicagoHowever, don't expect the nasal wearable to be able to reproduce more complex scents. Simulating a wider range of flavors might be possible, Brooks said, but not just by stimulating the trigeminal nerve. The olfactory bulb has a much wider range of sensations. The trigeminal nerve is more like the tongue, which can only recognize five flavors: sweet, sour, salty, bitter, and umami. (Much of the subtlety of what we call taste is actually smell.) Similarly, stimulation of the trigeminal nerve can produce great sensations that we recognize as smell, but without notes. In other words, while you can mimic the tingling sensation of vinegar fumes, you cannot do the same with the smell of fresh rain.
To stimulate the olfactory bulb, a lengthy nasal swab under medical supervision is required, which compares a COVID test to blowing your nose. Brooks found that the optimal way to stimulate the olfactory bulb would be with a tiny medical implant, although this is unlikely for most of us. There is also the challenge of replicating smells at the code level. “We don't know the parameters to actually digitally or electrically encode a smell so that it can then be correctly decoded by the light bulb,” they said.
The usefulness of olfactory technology
As for the use cases, the most obvious one is to make virtual reality more immersive. No matter how good the graphics may be, whether we have mastered the ability to walk infinitely in virtual reality or work on haptic technology to feel textures and objects in the virtual world, a VR pine forest is always in motion for many Appear poor if it doesn't smell like pine trees.
Brooks doesn't see this as a pure gaming accessory, however. "We already have phenomenal smell experiences that we may not pay too much attention to in real life that are just super rich," they said. “You are walking down the street and a smell is coming your way. There's a pretty famous chocolate factory in Chicago, and in the city all you get is clouds of that smell. I imagine that this could lead to a purely olfactory augmented reality ... that really changes our interaction with everyday smells, rather than trying to create new olfactory experiences from scratch. "
This work, still in the future for the team, could focus on making the smell experience smarter. Where does a certain smell come from? Can you turn up one smell that you liked and another that you didn't like? How about odor notifications: who doesn't want that sharp wasabi stinging sensation when their boss sends them messages on Slack? Or, more seriously, could you be tricked into smelling a deadly gas like carbon monoxide that is currently odorless? While carbon monoxide detectors do this without the user having to stick electrodes up their nose, such a tool could be useful for certain scenarios, such as rescue workers.
"One of the things we think about is can we use this as an intervention technology like hearing aids for people with odor loss?" Brooks pointed out that in a post-pandemic world with persistent odor loss that is a predominant side effect for many people , could become more urgent.
And of course there is still the option for other types of sensory entertainment beyond VR and gaming. "The chemical senses are so intense it is hard to imagine a three-hour olfactory opera that would stimulate you continuously for three hours and not pause," said Brooks. But the idea is certainly tempting. "I've been thinking about how much I would personally enjoy a Walkman scent for the past year and a half."
The idea of choosing a playlist of scent landscapes - from the smell of tomatoes on the vine to the aroma of fabric softener - and playing each one as needed is the stuff tech dreams are made of. Far fetched, perhaps. But not impossible. "That's definitely out of the question," said Brooks.
A paper describing the work of the team was recently presented at the Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI) 2021. In addition to Brooks, laboratory managers Pedro Lopes, Romain Nith, Shan-Yuan Teng, Jingxuan Wen and Jun Nishida worked on the project.
Editor's recommendations
https://dailytechnonewsllc.com/nose-zapping-wearable-simulates-smells-with-electricity/
Comments
Post a Comment