Greek borrowers gradually resume payments on €19.2B of moratorium loans
Greece's "Big Four" banks put a total of EUR 19.2 billion in loans on hold during the pandemic to protect borrowers from default. Just over a year after the onset of the crisis, many of these customers have been repaid in full with debt moratoriums. When borrowers have not been able to resume payments as usual, the Greek government has made a number of subsidies available to avoid defaults. This is good news for a banking system plagued by failures - both real and strategic - during the last credit cycle.
Even so, an increase in non-performing loans seems inevitable. The Bank of Greece, the country's central bank, estimates that Greek banks could book around 8 billion euros €10 billion new NPLs in 2021.
light at the end of the tunnel
Most debt moratoriums ended in late March, and lenders have reportedly not been hit by a wave of defaults Yiannis Mouzakis, Managing Director at MacroPolis, a think tank dealing with economic and political affairs in Greece.
"So far, a combination of initiatives by banks and the state has put the credit institutions in front of a comprehensive formation of "he said in an email.
One such initiative is the Gefyra or "Bridges" program, where the government subsidizes the repayment of mortgages on the primary homes of borrowers who have run into trouble. Gefyra, which went into effect in 2020, effectively replaces the Katseli Act, which was introduced in 2010 to protect heavily indebted homeowners from foreclosures, but which received widespread criticism for its misuse by strategic defaulters. The Greek government published a bill called "Gefyra 2" in March, which aims to provide similar subsidies to corporate borrowers.
The two systems seem to be already mitigating the failures at the major Greek banks.
Piraeus Financial Holdings SA has frozen overall Loans of EUR 5.0 billion have been granted since the start of the pandemic, and around EUR 500 million was covered by Gefyra at the end of February 2021 after the moratoria ended. The bank expects that a further 1.2 billion euros will be covered either by Gefyra 2 or by internal "step-up solutions". Loans of around EUR 200 million have already defaulted, and a further EUR 800 million are expected. Piraeus said that of the total loans subject to moratoriums, 45% is expected to return naturally to repayment status.
At Eurobank Ergasias Services and Holdings SA, 20% of the total loans granted under moratoria amounting to EUR 4.9 billion are either covered by Gefyra 1 or taken over in Gefyra 2, while 42% according to a presentation of the results for 2020 as a whole. Of the EUR 5.5 billion loans placed under moratoria by Alpha Services and Holdings SA, 10% are covered by Gefyra, and 63% are once again performing, the bank announced in its latest results presentation.
Repayment culture
Greek banks were plagued by strategic failures in the years following the global financial crisis in 2009. However, according to Nikolaos Artavanis, assistant professor of finance at Pamplin College of Business at Virginia Tech, history does not seem to repeat itself with coronavirus moratoria.
A strategic default is a conscious decision by the borrower to stop repaying loans even though they have the funds.
""We are currently seeing lower rates of strategically Standard compared to the past (i.e. Katseli's law). This doesn't necessarily reflect a change in the repayment culture. In my opinion, this is more likely to be attributed to the fact that recent credit market interventions in Greece (Gefyra and Coronavirus moratoria) were targeted, with specific eligibility criteria and strict conditions for the future behavior of the borrower, "he said in an email.
Ioannis Spyridopoulos, Assistant Professor of Finance at the American University's Kogod School of Business in Washington, DC, agrees that changing borrowers' attitudes may not be the reason for the lower frequency of strategic defaults.
""What has changed a lot is the macroeconomic environment and the feeling of political stability, "he said in an email.
The threat of a "total collapse" of the Greek economy, particularly the looming possibility of a "Grexit" in the mid-2010s, has had a strong impact on certain borrowers and may have been an incentive for some to deliberately abandon their loans, he said.
According to a "conservative estimate", in 2013 around 37% of the arrears on Greek residential mortgage loans granted between those years were identified 2006 and 2010 were strategic Artavanis and Spyridopoulos argued in an article published in February.
Greece almost left the single currency in 2015 after Brussels had a tense conflict over its national debt and the terms of its bailout.
Now that Greece is on a more stable footing, chances are borrowers will be more likely to recoup loans if they are able to. Said Spyridopoulos.
S&P Global Ratings announced on April 23 that Greece's GDP is expected to grow 4.9% in 2021, before rising to 5.8% in 2022. This compares to an 8.2% decrease in 2020 due to the pandemic. The rating agency has also upgraded the country's long-term country rating from BB to BB due to the improved effectiveness of the government and confirmed the short-term rating at B.
Add to the bad debt stack
While Greek banks are unlikely to face overwhelming NPL inflows due to the pandemic, it comes at a time when the country is still grappling with a large overhang from the last credit cycle, new bad debt losses. According to the Bank of Greece, the Greek banks still had NPLs totaling EUR 47.4 billion by the end of December 2020. The NPL rate is high at 30.2% compared to a European average of 2.6%.
The concern is that the combination of NPLs from the last credit cycle and the coronavirus crisis leaves Greek banks with limited scope to write new loans to the productive economy, according to Eleni Louri-Dendrinou, professor at Athens University of Economics.
"Funding growth with such high NPLs will be difficult," she said in an email.
read more
Comments
Post a Comment